Psychology

What Changes When Cannabis Cognition Studies Set a Longer Waiting Period?

·

A clock, calendar and response keyboard in a cognitive testing room.

A research paper can describe its participants as frequent cannabis users without telling you whether their last use was last night or last week. For a study of memory or attention, that missing detail changes the question. A young adult who sits down for a test the morning after using cannabis and one who has been abstinent for several weeks belong in the same box on a recruitment form. They arrive at the testing room under different conditions.

Researchers have tried two approaches to this problem. One is to sort existing studies by the waiting period they required. Another is to recruit people who already use cannabis and follow their performance through a period of abstinence. The first has the advantage of scale. The second comes closer to following a change as it happens.

Sorting sixty-nine studies by the clock

A meta-analysis in JAMA Psychiatry combined sixty-nine studies of cognitive functioning in adolescents and young adults. Across the full set, people reporting frequent or heavy use had somewhat lower average test scores than comparison participants. To combine tests that used different scales, the team expressed the difference in units of the variation among participants. The overall gap was about a quarter of a standard deviation.

The authors then opened up the category of cannabis use. Twenty-two studies either required no waiting period or did not specify one. Thirty-two required between one and seventy-two hours. Fifteen required more than seventy-two hours. In that last group the estimated difference was smaller, about eight hundredths of a standard deviation. Its confidence interval included zero. The available data were compatible with a small difference in either direction.

Three days can look like a promising cutoff when it appears as a line dividing two groups in a figure. Here the researchers chose it to organize studies. They did not test every participant at seventy-one hours and then again at seventy-three. Nobody’s personal recovery time can be read from the point where they drew the line.

A later appointment can mean a different sample

Requiring a longer wait can change who volunteers or who completes a study. A person who is willing and able to stop for a week may differ from someone who signs up for an afternoon of testing. During that wait, withdrawal-related changes in sleep are another potential influence on a test morning for some frequent users. The studies can also differ in their tasks, their recruitment sites and the way they verify last use. Combining them statistically does not erase those distinctions.

Nor did all participants start from the same place before they used cannabis. In two longitudinal studies of twins, researchers compared intelligence scores across adolescence and examined differences within families. The within-pair comparisons raised questions about how much of the association could be attributed to cannabis itself. An IQ score across years measures something different from a list learned this afternoon. The family study is valuable here because it shows how the comparison group can change the explanation.

Watching one person learn another list

A month-long abstinence experiment took a different route. Adolescents and young adults who used cannabis regularly were randomly assigned to monitored abstinence or a monitoring comparison condition. The researchers repeated cognitive tests and checked abstinence biochemically. Verbal learning improved in the abstinence group, with the change appearing chiefly in the first week. Attention performance improved with repeated testing in both groups.

Practice is one reason the comparison matters. On a second visit, a participant already knows the rhythm of the test and what sort of details will matter later. A better second score by itself could reflect that familiarity. A comparison group returning on the same schedule allows the researchers to estimate how much improvement accompanies another encounter with the test.

For a reader looking at the next headline about cannabis and cognition, the most informative detail may be buried in the methods: the interval since last use and how it was established. A result from that afternoon can describe how a particular group performed that afternoon. Following the same volunteers into the next week opens a different window onto what can change.