Psychology

Whose Idea Sounds Better After Cannabis?

·

An evaluator reviewing idea cards beside a guitar case.

In one experiment, a local band with the decidedly unglamorous name File Drawers needed help making money. Volunteers had five minutes to come up with ideas. Then they graded their own suggestions. Elsewhere in the same study, participants rated ideas about fitness equipment that someone else had supplied. The second assignment was more revealing than it might sound. If the idea on the page stays the same and the grade changes, something has happened to the judge.

The band was fictional. The broader question was familiar to anyone who has loved an idea one evening and looked at it differently the next morning. When people report feeling creative after using cannabis, does the change appear in the work, in their judgment of the work, or in both?

Give the same idea two audiences

In two experiments by Yu Tse Heng and colleagues, people who already used cannabis were assigned to a use or abstinence condition. Participants assessed their mood and tackled short creative tasks. In the first experiment the object was a brick. Finding an unexpected use for one gives a researcher something fairly easy to collect: a few words that can be copied onto a score sheet without identifying their author.

Two trained raters, unaware of the experimental assignment, judged more than two thousand brick ideas for novelty and usefulness. A person might think of a beautifully odd use that is almost impossible to carry out, or a practical use that everybody else thinks of too. Looking at both qualities makes it harder for sheer eccentricity to stand in for creativity.

Participants who used cannabis tended to report a more jovial mood and to give their own creativity a more favorable assessment. The outside evaluators, reading the ideas without knowing who had used cannabis, gave the two sets of answers similar marks. This separation is easy to miss if the only question on a survey is whether cannabis makes the respondent feel more creative. An honest answer to that question can be a poor prediction of someone else’s grade.

The fitness equipment belonged to somebody else

In the band experiment, participants also reviewed proposals for new pieces of exercise equipment. The researchers presented a common pool of ideas whose quality varied. An upbeat evaluation in this part of the task could hardly come from pride in authorship: the participant hadn’t designed the equipment. The research materials give the assignments behind the comparison.

The researchers found evidence linking the more favorable evaluations of other people’s ideas to joviality as well. That makes a modest but important difference to the interpretation. Someone who likes their own suggestion may simply be fond of it. Someone who also likes an unchanged suggestion from a stranger appears to be bringing a more generous standard, or a more receptive mood, to the job of judging.

What counts as a good idea?

An independent rating is still a human judgment. The idea of obtaining independent judgments has a long history in psychology, including Teresa Amabile’s early work on assessing creativity. Training and blinding help keep the comparison fair. They cannot turn a five-minute exercise into a test of whether an audience would buy a ticket, a manufacturer could build a prototype or a musician would find an idea worth working on for six months. Those outcomes have their own audiences and time scales.

A separate placebo-controlled experiment with regular cannabis users illustrates another wrinkle. It measured divergent thinking, the ability to generate varied answers to an open question, under different THC conditions. The high-potency condition impaired performance on the task. That finding concerns a particular dose and a particular kind of output. It need not contradict a study about how generously people evaluate an idea that already exists.

Imagine keeping three notes from the File Drawers assignment: the suggestion itself, the author’s immediate rating and a reader’s later assessment after the name and condition have been removed. Each preserves something worth knowing. Only the first gives the band an idea to try. The other two tell us about the people who thought it deserved a chance.